Discussion Starter: Do Teachers Get Paid Enough?

This post will be the first in a series I’m calling “Discussion Starters.” I’m going to present topics in education with the intention of encouraging conversation amongst readers in the comments. I’ll share some of my thoughts in each post. Readers can take over the conversation from there.

For the first Discussion Starter, I’m going with teacher salary. Specifically, I’m asking if readers feel teachers get paid enough.

Speaking from my experience, I can say I got paid plenty. My salary as a teacher was beyond what I needed. Admittedly, lived a different lifestyle than most of my colleagues lived. I had no car, no mortgage, and no children. With so few expenses, I didn’t long for any more than I earned. Living and working where I did helped, being in a city and state known for relatively high teacher salaries. I’ll acknowledge that my experience might have been atypical, which sets up my overall feelings about the matter.

The fairness of salary is somewhat relative. Within a given district, individual teachers will vary in how they can make what they earn work for them. Additionally, earnings at different steps range dramatically in many districts. Both of these factors are true of other fields. Salaries vary significantly from district to district and state to state. Some are better matched to proportionate costs of living then others. Again, this range is true of other fields, but the range is especially great in education.

So salaries are relative. Are they fair per the level of education and responsibilities teachers have? One must remember most teachers are paid for ten months of work and for shorter work days than most have in other professions. Their gross pay should be considered per the number of hours they work. Even if their gross seems low compared with other fields, they tend to receive extraordinary and low-cost benefits. Despite a ten month calendar, most also enjoy generous paid leave. These factors start to make teacher earnings look appropriate.

I’ve not included some intangibles, such as the complexity of what teachers face each day, or the absurd hours some choose (and “choose” is crucial here) to spend outside regular work hours planning, preparing, and grading. I’m not about to say teachers don’t put in a difficult slog. I do think the value of their salaries depends on where they teach and how they decide to live their lives in relation to their salaries. Considering their actual contractual responsibilities, their salaries be justified.

What do you think? Chime in via the comments section.

Discussion Starter: Do Teachers Get Paid Enough?

4 thoughts on “Discussion Starter: Do Teachers Get Paid Enough?

  1. Hi Jeffrey, You didn’t mention the incentive of completely excusing one’s school loan. I have mixed feelings since I know some teachers loathe teaching but are only doing it because they don’t know what else to do about the massive school loan. I have doubts about using this bribery as incentive. I’m not sure it will attract the best people for the job.


  2. The federal program for loan forgiveness applies to very specific schools and tends to be reserved by default for teachers at the beginning of their careers who have yet to take on expenses such as homeownership or childrearing. It also requires five years of consecutive teaching at a high-needs school for up to $17,000 of loan forgiveness. “Up to” is critical; most get back more like $5000. I’ve not seen stats on how many teachers are taking advantage of this, but I’m not certain the incentive is enough to keep many teachers in the eligible schools.


  3. No. with the amount of time I have spent in college. The amount of time I spend outside my school doing work. Choose yes, but if I chose no, I would be reprimanded. The stress of paperwork, changing, unreliable, technology and increasing challenging students. No.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s